--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pete,
Thanks for the reply. Fortunately, I have just completed the job this evening. Having now removed all 20 cam carrier bolts, I managed to stip out 7 of the 20. I have pasted in, below, my lessons learned that I just posted over on the Rennlist board. My saviour, was some Yankee ingenuity suggested by Raj over on the Rennliste site. If you take a 12mm 12 point socket, you can get it to cut into the OD of the stipped bolt head using a ball pein hammer. Since the bolt heads are very soft, driving the socket onto the bolt is very easy. Once installed (squarely), I used my breaker bar to break 6 of the 7 bolts loose. No doubt that your suggested technique would have worked also.
I have pasted in the text of my last posting on the Rennlist board that provides my "lessons learned" from the ordeal of working with these dead soft bolts. Here it is:
Success at last! Well, I finally succeeded in breaking loose all 20 cam carrier bearing cap bolts. Did not have to drill any out, either. For those that have not attempted this yet, here are "my" lessons learned:
1. Your triple square socket absolutely must remain square to the bolt that you are attempting to break loose. And, your breaker bar must be perfectly perpendicular to the socket. If the tool is tilted at all, you will strip out the bolt, as I managed to do seven times! Do not use a long triple square socket. Instead get the shortest socket you can find. Since I was desperate, I bought the Snap-on socket; however, I still managed to strip out (7) out of (20) bolts with the Snap-on.
2. If you do not believe #1, take a close look at the bolt head. The heads are about half the heighth of standard socket head cap screws. The serrations on the inside diameter of the bolt head are only partial length, so to the naked eye it looks like the total length of the serrations that engage the triple square socket are less than 1/4". That's not much bearing surface if you at attempting to put 40 to 50 ft-lbs of torque into breaking the bolts loose.
3. Although the installation of new bolts calls for about 15 ft-lbs of torque, it took 4 to 5 times that amount of torque to break the bolts loose. My engine has about 90K miles on it, and this appears to be the first time these bolts have been removed.
4. The triple sqaure bolts do not appear to be hardened, but are rather "soft" which makes stripping them very easy. They are probably designed to be soft so that they can take the stretch that will occur when the light alloy parts they are joining heat up and expand. The coefficient of expansion for alloy is much greater than the steel bolt material, which means that alloy will expand, when heated, more than the steel bolts; so, the bolts will be forced to stretch every time the engine is heated up. I would not advise replacing the bolts with bolts of a material that is hardened, or you may begin to experience bolt failures over time, since the hardened bolts will be less ductile than the soft ones. Without ductility, you could begin to see stress fractures in the bolts over time, which would not be good since the bolt will then break. I believe that is the reason Porsche designed the bolting to be ductile (soft).
5. Raj's ingenious trick of using a 12 point 12mm Sears socket to grab the outside diameter of any bolts that had been stripped out worked like a champ. Of the 20 bolts that required removal, I managed to strip out (7) of them. Six of the seven were fairly easy to remove by lightly hammering the 12mm socket around the head of the bolt and then using the breaker bar to break the bolt loose. Again, you must be ABSOLUTELY square with the bolt you are attempting to remove, or you can round off the ouside diameter of the bolt. For the single bolt that I managed to do that to, I was faced with drilling out the bolt; but, in one last desparate move, I used the rounded end of my small ball pein hammer to tap on the head of the bolt. This caused the soft bolt head to mushroom out just enough to allow me to force fit the 12 mm socket once again. I was very careful to keep the socket and the breaker bar square with the bolt, and the bolt broke loose. If that failed, I proabably would have drilled out the bolt head.
6. Since the bolt material is soft and ductile, I suspect that it should be relativly easy to drill out the head, though I was spared the "opportunity" to have to do that this time around.
7. If you don't like the idea of drilling out the head, I suspect that you could use a Dremel tool fitted with a 1-1/2 inch cutoff wheel to slice the head off from the side. Since there is a rather thick aluminum washer below each bolt, you should be able to slice off the head without hitting the bearing cap. Instead, you will damage the crush washers, which is ok since you need to discard them anyway.
So, not such a bad deal afterall. My thanks to Raj for his Yankee ingenuity! Hopefully, the rest of job will go more easilly. Keep your fingers crossed!
Ernie