insurance companies are always inclined to pay you more if they're confident they have a strong subrogation recovery potential ( as was the case where you get hit from behind while stopped at a light..) still, regardless of that, i completely agree about fighting them for every penny you can get, particularly with our cars where "market comparables" are extremely rare ( condition, mileage, etc, etc..) so that argument does not really hold much water as it would if you had your Toyota or Honda totaled.. But "at the end of the day", Agreed Value policies are the optimum solution ( in case your 968 is totaled )