Posts: 577
Threads: 11
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation:
0
I couldnt agree more. So many 951's are being converted its sickening. I tell people all the time Mezger didnt design the rest of the car for a powerband like that. I dont understand why people dont just buy a vette. Apples, and oranges. Not to mention I'll never buy a GM product, ever.
86' India red 951 3.0 8v turbo
87' Guards red 951 parts car(scrapped :-( )
93' GP white 968 manual, coupe(restoration/modifications in progress)
"I couldn't find the sports car of my dreams, so I built it myself."Ferdinand Porsche
Posts: 3,017
Threads: 224
Joined: Mar 2006
Reputation:
0
[quote name='ds968' timestamp='1316810967' post='115803']
That's IT, you're permanently banned from this forum ! Oh, wait you're one of the forum owners.. umm,ok I got it : ban yourself from this forum ! Just for making a comment of that sort, you should be forewarned that I'll have my "second" travel over to your place, take off his glove and slap you into a duel challenge. Torque wreches at 50 paces.
[/quote]
<img src="/forum/images/smilies/968/icon_lol1.gif" class="smilie" alt="" />
I love my 968 for what it is & don't hate it for what it isn't!
Posts: 341
Threads: 3
Joined: Aug 2007
Reputation:
0
I don't know. There are plenty of 944 turbos and even a few 968 turbos out there that seem to get around pretty well with over 300whp. I have owned cars with more power, smaller brakes, skinnier wheels, a less stiff chassis and it all worked out.
The appeal of the V8 for me is nice fat midrange and decent top-end power, and running a motor designed to deliver that kind of power without expense or drama. For some racers, hitting a target HP level with a reliable engine that is not high strung or even expensive to replace is their goal. The turbo guys are generally more inclined to do the swap as many of them already shoot for higher HP levels and have seen the cost and reliability of the high HP turbo configurations. Some already have an investment int he chassis they do not want to walk away from.
I have looked at Corvettes and they just do not excite me. It'd be hard to spend that fair bit of money and still feel like it's just not what I wanted. The issue is that there is just nothing I can come up with that I would be excited about at a price point I am comfortable with or even at a price point I am somewhat daunted by. Having to get the top down makes all this very difficult, If I wanted a coupe I'd just get a 928GT and go drive. Maybe I'll waffle long enough for a used 650ic 6MT to come down to $30k or so.
I personally would not ruin a steak with A1 sauce or by cooking it well-done but if that's what you like, go for it.
Joel Frahm
1992 968 Cabrio Black/Cashmere
1994 968 Cabrio Iris Blue/Lt. Grey - Supercharged
1987 928S4 Diamondblau/Blue
Posts: 32
Threads: 11
Joined: Jul 2010
Reputation:
0
Reminds me of all the MGB's that had small block V8's stuffed in them, the ones that worked looked really hacked up. I think a lot of backyard mechanics found out it wasnt so easy to be Carroll Shelby. <img src="/forum/images/smilies/968/smile.png" class="smilie" alt="" /> I agree wiht jfram, and start with a 928 if you want that V8 power, or if you want to live dangerously, get a Sunbeam Tiger, complete with the skinny tires and a lot of hp. It is also much more fun to see peoples faces when describing the 3 liter 4 cylinder engine in the 968.
030: Sport Group
220: Locking Differential
241: Shorter Shifting Travel
331: AM/FM Cassette!
383: Sport Seat-Left
387: Sport Seat-Right
490: "Hi-Fi" (not so sure about that one)
Posts: 439
Threads: 46
Joined: Nov 2008
Reputation:
0
[quote name='flash' timestamp='1316788427' post='115792']
i'm not that much of a purist, as i really hate porsches to begin with, [/quote]
WTF???? Hate Porsches and think people don't like the Z8? You just dropped a few pegs on the respect meter....
Benspeeder
BigSpeed Racing
1992 ITR Porsche 968
1998 Boxster
2003 F350 V10 XLT Super Duty - hauler
1995 Georgie Boy Cruise Air - 37 ft Coach race car hauler
Posts: 577
Threads: 11
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation:
0
[quote name='jfrahm' timestamp='1316963558' post='115865']
The appeal of the V8 for me is nice fat midrange and decent top-end power, and running a motor designed to deliver that kind of power without expense or drama. For some racers, hitting a target HP level with a reliable engine that is not high strung or even expensive to replace is their goal. The turbo guys are generally more inclined to do the swap as many of them already shoot for higher HP levels and have seen the cost and reliability of the high HP turbo configurations.
[/quote]
I guess I wouldnt call a 3.0 with 17ish psi "high strung". Thats good for high 300's hp to the wheels. Well into 400's tq. With the right turbo, and tune, etc, plenty of mid range grunt. Now, a 3.0 I4 with 30. 40, 50 psi....thats high strung. Even into the 20's with the deck still open is getting high strung. The 951 is rated to about 500. Beyond that things like to twist, and ring, and pinions like to snap, axles break, etc. The 968 with a slightly stiffer tub, and stronger transaxle is good for about 600. Beyond that its quite a sllippery slope. The only reason I would understand a v8 swap, is because with moderate boost, really big numbers are possible. ie: 1000's. But the rest of the car just isnt up to the task. The I4 under boost is perfect. You can achieve similar numbers as a NA v8, and still be pretty darn reliable. I'll admit a newer lsx engine is a bit more reliable. But are belt changes really that horrible? Under heavy track conditions I would see the I4 needing dry sump too IMO. Then there is the whole OHC, vs pushrod thing....meh The I4 has no problem maxing out the capabilities of the car with boost. Then there is always the option to go to a 3.2. Its simply not a really high HP capable car. Not reliable, and arguably streetable with any motor. If I wanted that id buy a vette or supra. Im perfectly happy with a 4-500 hp street car. No desire to have more, not in these relatively light cars. The newer vettes are very similar, like a 968 with different curves, and fiberglass. Same basic lay out. Whatever floats your boat man. Just my opinion. Admittedly I dont llike seeing another 968 fall victim to a renegade hybrids conversion, they are not a dim e a dozen. Neither are 951's really either. At the current rate, parts will become more rare. But, thats why I have an entire other car in parts, and a couple complete motors, sitting on the shelf LOL. People are gonna do what they want with their cars.
To me, if people want to throw a GM motor in to save money, they shouldnt have bought a Porsche. Part of the fun is wrenching on it. If people didnt expect it to be expensive.....uh....buy American....err Mexican/American, or wherever they are currently outsourcing assembly to these days. I mean, i didnt buy a Porsche thinking yeah, this is gonna be light on the wallet....ya know? As the saying goes "there are no cheap Porsches"
86' India red 951 3.0 8v turbo
87' Guards red 951 parts car(scrapped :-( )
93' GP white 968 manual, coupe(restoration/modifications in progress)
"I couldn't find the sports car of my dreams, so I built it myself."Ferdinand Porsche
Posts: 341
Threads: 3
Joined: Aug 2007
Reputation:
0
I think it is fair to say a 17 psi boosted 4 cylinder turbo is more "high strung" than a stock Camaro V8 but a semantic argument does not interest me.
I agree that if the car you want is already built by a factory and available at your price point you should buy that car rather than convert or create the car you want. A good example of this is the 944 Turbo. People who want to turbo a 944 are better off buying the factory example IMO rather than converting an NA. But what if you look for a factory example of the car you want and come up empty?
The funny thing is that your own .sig makes my argument: '"I couldn't find the sports car of my dreams, so I built it myself."
Ferdinand Porsche'
I'm still looking for the sports car of my dreams and if I have to build it, and I have the time, so be it.
-Joel.
Joel Frahm
1992 968 Cabrio Black/Cashmere
1994 968 Cabrio Iris Blue/Lt. Grey - Supercharged
1987 928S4 Diamondblau/Blue