12-28-2012, 11:21 AM
When we last left this intrepid doityourselfer, I was happy with the way my Darton wet sleeved engine was running. Hah.
First sign of trouble was a clicking noise. Lifters? I pulled the cams and the lifters all looked great. Rod bearing? I pulled the pan (huge pita job), and they all looked great. I checked compression and, oops, #1, 2 and 3 were all close to 200 followed "closely" by #4 at 15. A leakdown test showed that 1, 2 and 3 weren't all that great and #4 had a huge leak down. Running the car in the shop I also noticed oil smoke coming out of the oil filler pipe.
I stuck a boroscope in the cylinders and could see vertical scoring on both sides of the #4 bore. So off with the head. It was not pretty. The walls of #4 were a mess and I could see signs of similar problems starting in the other 3. First picture shows this scoring. So out came the engine for about the fourth time.
The next picture shows the #4 piston. The top compression ring was literally welded into the ring land. Ugly.
So what was the problem? With my concurrence my shop honed the bores of the sleeves to the factory spec clearance. This is actually less than 0.001" which is a very tight clearance. And it may work well with an aluminum piston in an aluminum non-sleeved block. But it sure isn't enough for an aluminum piston in a ductile iron sleeve. This is especially true of a boosted engine. The piston's at temperature diameter matched or exceeded the bore diameter galling the piston and wall badly.
I could give up, but what fun is that. The goal was to save this block, and I'm still not ready to quit. After a lot of research and discussion I decided on a clearance of .0045". I also decided to stick with stock pistons. I custom ordered rings and I will also use larger ring gaps. Last night the honing was completed (picture 3). I can now start yet another assembly.
Many thanks to Flash, Andy, Pete, Mike of Lindsey Racing and other resources. All have been tremendously helpful to me in working through this.
...to be continued
First sign of trouble was a clicking noise. Lifters? I pulled the cams and the lifters all looked great. Rod bearing? I pulled the pan (huge pita job), and they all looked great. I checked compression and, oops, #1, 2 and 3 were all close to 200 followed "closely" by #4 at 15. A leakdown test showed that 1, 2 and 3 weren't all that great and #4 had a huge leak down. Running the car in the shop I also noticed oil smoke coming out of the oil filler pipe.
I stuck a boroscope in the cylinders and could see vertical scoring on both sides of the #4 bore. So off with the head. It was not pretty. The walls of #4 were a mess and I could see signs of similar problems starting in the other 3. First picture shows this scoring. So out came the engine for about the fourth time.
The next picture shows the #4 piston. The top compression ring was literally welded into the ring land. Ugly.
So what was the problem? With my concurrence my shop honed the bores of the sleeves to the factory spec clearance. This is actually less than 0.001" which is a very tight clearance. And it may work well with an aluminum piston in an aluminum non-sleeved block. But it sure isn't enough for an aluminum piston in a ductile iron sleeve. This is especially true of a boosted engine. The piston's at temperature diameter matched or exceeded the bore diameter galling the piston and wall badly.
I could give up, but what fun is that. The goal was to save this block, and I'm still not ready to quit. After a lot of research and discussion I decided on a clearance of .0045". I also decided to stick with stock pistons. I custom ordered rings and I will also use larger ring gaps. Last night the honing was completed (picture 3). I can now start yet another assembly.
Many thanks to Flash, Andy, Pete, Mike of Lindsey Racing and other resources. All have been tremendously helpful to me in working through this.
...to be continued

