08-11-2010, 12:31 AM
Craig,
I agree with your mechanic that it seems unusual that your clutch failed so early. I have read on other forums that some clutch friction disc types are more prone to failure than others, with a common failure being shearing of the studs that hold the material on, resulting in chunks being discarded from the backing plate. Do you know what brand of clutch disc was used for the replacement(s)?
My guess is that the clutch failure may have contributed to the synchro failure through binding with the pressure plate during gear changes. For reference, the clutch in my S2 is a Porsche supplied replacement - no problems after 4 years of mainly track use (and still has around half of the friction material left on it). Perhaps I'm just not as hard on mine with downshifts?
Eric
I agree with your mechanic that it seems unusual that your clutch failed so early. I have read on other forums that some clutch friction disc types are more prone to failure than others, with a common failure being shearing of the studs that hold the material on, resulting in chunks being discarded from the backing plate. Do you know what brand of clutch disc was used for the replacement(s)?
My guess is that the clutch failure may have contributed to the synchro failure through binding with the pressure plate during gear changes. For reference, the clutch in my S2 is a Porsche supplied replacement - no problems after 4 years of mainly track use (and still has around half of the friction material left on it). Perhaps I'm just not as hard on mine with downshifts?
Eric